Which of the following statements about the advantage of roasting of sulphide ore before reduction is not true?
- The fG of the sulphide is greater than those for CS2 and H2S.
- The fG is negative for roasting of sulphide ore to oxide.
- Roasting of the sulphide to the oxide is thermodynamically feasible.
- Carbon and hydrogen are suitable reducing agents for metal sulphides.
Answer
(4) Carbon and hydrogen are suitable reducing agents for metal sulphides.
Solution
∵ fG of a metal sulphide is more negative than that of CS2 and H2S (CS2 is in fact an endothermic compound),
⇒ rG for 2MS + C 2M + CS2 and MS + H2 M + H2S is positive.
⇒ Carbon and hydrogen cannot reduce metal sulphides, so statement (4) is not true.
As per NCERT, sulphide ores are therefore first roasted to oxides, e.g. 2ZnS + 3O2 2ZnO + 2SO2; this change has negative G , i.e., it is thermodynamically feasible (statements (2) and (3) true).
⇒ The oxide is then easily reduced by carbon, e.g. ZnO + C coke, 1673 K Zn + CO.
∴ The statement that is not true is (4).
Answer: (4)