The reaction of hydrogen and iodine monochloride is given as: H2(g) + 2ICl(g) 2HCl(g) + I2(g) This reaction is of first order with respect to H2(g) and ICl(g). The following mechanisms were proposed. Mechanism A: H2(g) + 2ICl(g) 2HCl(g) + I2(g) Mechanism B: H2(g) + ICl(g) HCl(g) + HI(g); slow HI(g) + ICl(g) HCl(g) + I2(g); fast Which of the above mechanism(s) can be consistent with the given information about the reaction?
- A and B both
- Neither A nor B
- A only
- B only
Answer
(4) B only
Solution
Observed rate law: Rate = k[H2][ICl] (first order in each).
Mechanism A is a single elementary step, so its rate law follows its stoichiometry:
Rate = k[H2][ICl]2 ⇒ second order in ICl, which does not agree.
Mechanism B: as per NCERT, the slowest step is the rate-determining step.
∴ Rate = k[H2][ICl] ⇒ first order in H2 and in ICl, which agrees.
Also, adding the two steps of B gives the overall reaction H2 + 2ICl 2HCl + I2.
∴ Only mechanism B is consistent.
Answer: (4)