Designate whether each of the following compounds is aromatic or not aromatic. [figure]
- a, c, d, e, h aromatic and b, f, g not aromatic
- b, e, f, g aromatic and a, c, d, h not aromatic
- a, b, c, d aromatic and e, f, g, h not aromatic
- e, g aromatic and a, b, c, d, f, h not aromatic
Answer
(1) a, c, d, e, h aromatic and b, f, g not aromatic
Solution
A species is aromatic if it is cyclic, planar, fully conjugated and has (4n+2) π electrons (Hückel rule).
(a) cyclopentadienyl anion: 4 π + lone pair in conjugation = 6 π (n = 1) aromatic
(b) cyclopentadienyl cation: 4 π (4n) not aromatic (antiaromatic)
(c) cyclobutadienyl dication: 2 π (n = 0) aromatic
(d) cyclobutadienyl dianion: 2 π + 4 electrons of the two carbanions = 6 π aromatic
(e) cycloheptatrienyl (tropylium) cation: 6 π aromatic
(f) cyclooctatetraene: 8 π, tub-shaped (non-planar) not aromatic
(g) cyclobutadiene: 4 π not aromatic (antiaromatic)
(h) cyclopropenyl cation: 2 π aromatic
a, c, d, e, h are aromatic and b, f, g are not aromatic.
Answer: (1)