Which of the following biphenyls is optically active ?
- [figure]
- [figure]
- [figure]
- [figure]
Answer
(4) [figure]
Solution
A substituted biphenyl shows optical activity (atropisomerism) when:
(i) bulky groups at the ortho positions restrict free rotation about the central C–C bond, so the two rings stay non-planar, and
(ii) each ring carries two different ortho groups, so the molecule has no plane of symmetry.
(1) Only one ortho group (I) on each ring ⇒ rotation is not sufficiently hindered and a symmetric conformation is accessible ⇒ inactive.
(2) Second ring is unsubstituted, and the first ring has identical ortho groups (CH3, CH3) ⇒ plane of symmetry ⇒ inactive.
(3) Only meta substituents ⇒ free rotation ⇒ inactive.
(4) Each ring has two different bulky ortho groups (Br and I) ⇒ rotation is restricted and the molecule is non-superimposable on its mirror image ⇒ optically active.
Answer: (4)