The pairs among A = [SO32-, CO32-], B = [O22-, F2], C = [CN-, CO], D = [NH3, H3O+] and E = [MnO42-, CrO42-] that do not have similar Lewis dot structure are
- A, B and E
- A and E
- B, C and D
- C and D
Answer
(2) A and E
Solution
Species with the same number of valence electrons and the same skeleton have similar Lewis dot structures.
B. O22- and F2: 14 valence electrons each; single bond, three lone pairs on each atom ⇒ similar
C. CN- and CO: 10 valence electrons each; triple bond, one lone pair on each atom ⇒ similar
D. NH3 and H3O+: 8 valence electrons each; three bond pairs and one lone pair on the central atom ⇒ similar
A. SO32- (26 valence electrons) has a lone pair on S (pyramidal); CO32- (24 valence electrons) has no lone pair on C (trigonal planar) ⇒ not similar
E. CrO42- (32 valence electrons): Cr(+6), 3d0, all electrons paired; MnO42- (33 valence electrons): Mn(+6), 3d1, one unpaired electron ⇒ not similar
∴ Pairs A and E do not have similar Lewis dot structures.
Answer: (2)